Little Boxes All the Same…

I was sick this past Monday, some weird and nasty crap in my throat. Since I was sick and not allowed near Liam I was effectively useless and sat around watching TV for the afternoon. Because my wife is such a wonderful woman she was kind enough to rent me the first season of Weeds. It’s friggin’ awesome. It’s a wonderful show that airs on Showtime (like so many wonderful programs…Dead Like Me [tragically cancelled] and Dexter for instance) about a 40ish year old suburban house-wife who’s husband died suddenly. In order to maintain her standard of living and to support her two sons (11 and 16 yrs old) she sells marijuana. How’s that for a concept? I’m guessing that a content warning is a little bit redundant at this point given the channel the show airs on and the concept but in case you care consider yourself content-warned.

I bring Weeds up first of all because it’s brilliant and hilarious, and secondly because it dovetails nicely with an essay I’ve been reading by Keven J. Vanhoozer. The essay is “Does the Trinity Belong in a Theology of Religions? – On Angling in the Rubicon and the ‘Identity’ of God” from his book First Theology. Vanhoozer’s essay is concerned with the totalizing tendencies of both exclusivist and pluralist versions of religious dialog. The exclusivist attempts to reduce all opinions to the Same through some kind of violence or coercion. Pluralism, interestingly enough, does the same, reducing all opinions to the Same through rhetoric particularly with the spectacularly arrogant assumption that we are all praying to the same God. Vanhoozer concludes with the suggestion that the trinitarian nature of God (God as we Christians see him that is) indicates a different way forward in which there are varying opinions and points of view and we discuss and persuade each other without violence, coercion or oversimplification. In other words, I don’t have to agree with you and you don’t have to agree with me but we can still talk about it. We aren’t the same and we shouldn’t be. We don’t have the same conception of God and that’s allowed. “We must remember that our theological formulations are always provisional; none of them catches the sacred fish” (Vanhoozer 68).

Back to Weeds. Maybe the best part of the show (after Mary Louise Parker that is) is the soundtrack. The creators of the program use a fantastic little ditty called “Little Boxes” by Malvina Reynolds as the title track for the show. It’s all about the horror of cookie-cutter culture and modern North American culture’s all but unstopable attempts to reduce us all to the Same. Almost as beautiful as the song itself is the fact that in seasons 2 and 3 the producers got a different artist to perform Reynolds’ song for every single episode. And each performance is a unique re-interpretation of the original.

The moral of the story? You aren’t the same as me. I’m not the same as you. Nor should we be. What to do when we disagree? Talk.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Little Boxes All the Same…

  1. I sometimes wonder if we speak the same language…Dude, I saw a few episodes of “Weeds” and, well, I wasn’t entertained by it. Nor was I challenged by it and I decided not to watch it anymore.By the way I agree that people can disagree and still talk, be friends and maybe even play ROOK.Seriously though, I feel dumb reading your blog sometimes… (and yes I realized I opened myself up there… go ahead; fire away).Good to see you blogging.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s